My Service Ratings
07/30/2026 - Paige Stought
My Service Ratings
07/15/2026 - Shawn Conatser
Shari is unfailingly patient, helpful, and knowledgeable. She went above and beyond to be available to us with insightful answers to our questions whenever we thought of them, and when we found the right place she was instrumental in guiding us into an offer that fit our budget and landed us our forever home. Shari was great with our two young kids, and made sure that they felt like they were included in the process. We never felt like a burden or were wasting her time, even when we could tell right away that something wasn't the right fit. A !
My Service Ratings
05/08/2026 - Susan Lubow
Shari is fabulous. She is extremely knowledgeable of the area and knows how to strategize on timing of offer, price, etc. She goes above and beyond to make sure that her clients are satisfied. Shari is extremely responsive, willing to work at any time. She has an emotional maturity that makes her intuitive as to what our needs are and how best to serve us. I would enthusiastically recommend her to anyone. Thanks!
My Service Ratings
03/10/2026 - John Konovodoff
Shari was fantastic to work with. Anyone can look at listings, but Shari went above and beyond finding additional listings that met my needs, diving into listings I liked and finding additional, pertinent information, always keeping in mind what mattered most to me. When the Seller required a best and final with a quick deadline, Shari was available at any hour of the day/night and helped me win the contract while I was on vacation. Her biggest lift and support came through the mortgage process. My mortgage company was a mess, changing their process and terms throughout the process. Shari was on top of all of it though. She knew what was needed of the mortgage company and knew how to guide them through their own process. Without her involvement, I know I would not have made it to the closing table. Overall, she was extremely helpful, effective, and easy to work with. 10/10 would recommend and I will absolutely work with Shari again in the future.
My Service Ratings
10/07/2025 - Jeff & Cathy Foster
We have worked with Shari Nutter on the purchaseor sale of 6 residential/investment properties over the last 4 years. Our high confidence in the services Shari offers are rooted in her professionalism, thorough knowledge of the market/real estate brokerage process, attention to detail, and ability to quickly develop rapport with seller/seller's agent. We definitely plan on leveraging Shari for future real estate transactions, and would highly recommend her services to anyone interested in selling/buying a property. Thanks again, Shari! Jeff & Cathy Foster
My Service Ratings
09/19/2025 - Jonathan Kaplan
Shari Nutter did a wonderful, conscientious job of selling our property. I would definitely use her again.
My Service Ratings
05/02/2025 - Mark Brickley
Shari had our home listed 2 days after we hired her and had an open house the same weekend. Stayed in constant contact throughout the process and was instrumental in walking us through the title process as well as being informed of expectations of proceeds upon closing. Couldn't be more happy with the experience and Sheri's professionalism. Would definitely recommend Sheri to anyone looking to buy or sale a property in Pickerington.
My Service Ratings
11/04/2024 - Leon & Kayla
Shari is by far the best realtor I've ever had the pleasure of working with. It's very apparent that she cares about the people she works with and is determined to find the home you're looking for. I can't thank Shari enough for going with us to look at all the houses we were interested in, no matter how rough, and sometimes a little dangerous, they were. You definitely made our home search an adventure and we greatly appreciate the time and patience you offered us through the process. Also, thanks for not mentioning that I was misspelling your name for almost a year (Sharri instead of Shari) even though it was in your in all your emails, business cards, etc... haha. Also, thanks for being kind enough to check in on us after the buying process was complete to see how we were doing with reno and getting moved in. You really are the best!
My Service Ratings
08/22/2023 - Brandon Buckley
Shari is the best! She helped our family navigate through all the details of our new home purchase. She was very professional, very knowledgeable, and has a great personality. Real pleasure to work with.
My Service Ratings
06/20/2023 - Beth & William Burns
I've known Shari for many years. She's a very good person. And she's awesome at her work. I knew she'd do a great job. She communicates so well. Always follows up on what she says she will. On top of that she was do much fun to work with. And she was amazing. Technically she sold our house is less than one day! Plus my husband loved the Buckeye schedules!!
My Service Ratings
01/27/2023 - Donna K.
Shari was amazing from start to finish! We would not have been able to navigate the home selling and buying process without her. She was very responsive and patient with us--and we were looking all over Columbus! She will be our agent for life!
My Service Ratings
12/05/2022 - Todd
Always a pleasure to work with Shari, very kind, caring and upbeat! Would not hesitate to work with again.
My Service Ratings
10/05/2022 - McKinley’s Reynoldsburg Ohio
We were purchasing a house long distance (we moved from NM to OH). She was responsive and attentive as well as being our advocate. We literally drove straight into town and to the closing. She even offered to sit in the RV with the puppies while we signed. Really great experience!
My Service Ratings
09/27/2022 - Thomas O Schnell
Shari was very helpful in dealing the potential buyers.
My Service Ratings
05/01/2022 - Marcus
Shari is an experienced realtor. Shari knows the Columbus market very well. We've worked with Shari on several housing deals through the years, and would gladly recommend her. My wife and I trust her explicitly.
My Service Ratings
04/28/2022 - Josh Elledge Southern Orchards
Shari is a great realtor and an even better person she always put our needs first and had our best interest in mind. She was always willing to help no matter what time of day and put us in situations to succeed and help us get our dream house. If anyone is looking for a house in the central Ohio area I would absolutely refer them to Shari.
My Service Ratings
09/14/2021 - Dottie LaChance Pickerington
On top of everything.Friendly, courteous, attentiveWhen a problem/question appeared, it was fixed with accuracyWhen the process was completed I felt like I had just made a new friend.
My Service Ratings
06/22/2021 - Douglas Crawford New Albany
Shari Nutter made the sale of our home as painless as possible. It was a pleasure to work with her and I would recommend her to anyone. She was professional and knowledgeable.
My Service Ratings
05/10/2021 - Jeff Foster
Overall very positive experience with Shari. Many challenges through out the process with lender. Shari often helped facilitate and helped to bridge the gap we had with lender.
My Service Ratings
11/29/2020 - Cathy A. Roszell. Lancaster
Shari Nutter IS a superb Real Estate Agent and human being. She is not only very knowledgeable, that is, regarding what it takes for a Purchaser to really KNOW about a purchase: the actual, valid, and legal ins-and-outs plus any attendant "variables" or "What Ifs?" : Shari's demonstrates keen intelligence, a vast knowledge-base, experience, confidence, personality, warm and caring ways, hence all of this and more, made her THE CHOICE for me. I have already recommended Shari Nutter to another person, who is contemplating (after COVID-19) to make a home purchase somewhere in the Lancaster/Logan/HideAway-Hills areas. Shari Nutter SIMPLY ROCKS!
My Service Ratings
09/19/2020 - Tom in Pickerington
Very knowledgable about real estate in general and currents in the real estate market in our area. Great, sale.
My Service Ratings
08/20/2020 - Emily
Shari was available as soon as we needed her, when another real estate company could not show us a house for a couple days. She showed us houses as soon as possible and always had our best interest in mind. Almost immediately she knew exactly what we were looking for and did her best to find something that fit all of our needs. Ultimately she was the one that was able to find the house we bought in this crazy market. She fought for us all the way through the buying process. Shari is knowledgeable and is truly great at what she does!Shari lead us through the closing process with ease. Although there were many hurdles to jump with our house, she flew through all of them. I'm so thankful that we were in her hands. She truly fights for her clients Immediately Shari felt like somebody we could trust. She was always available and knew exactly what we needed. She was friendly, professional, and so patient with us.Based on past experiences with buying and selling, Shari went above and beyond every expectation I had for a realtor. She sets the bar high.
My Service Ratings
08/04/2020 - Kelly Dawes
Shari was outstanding! We wanted to get our house on the market quickly and she helped make that happen! She had great suggestions on what we could do to make the house more marketable and worked with us to get it done! Shari was very knowledgeable of the market in our area and we got top dollar for our home! Shari's support and passion during this process has been very impressive!Our home sold the first day on the market and we had several offers. Shari did a great job navigating us through the offers so we understood everything!Shari exceeded our expectations! I would highly recommend her to family and friends!
My Service Ratings
06/01/2020 - Margaret Smith
Shari is very personable and supportive. She was always prompt when responding to questions and telephone calls. I felt very secure in her handling of the sale of my house. I would definitely refer people wanting to sell their home to Shari.
My Service Ratings
07/28/2019 - Mike Reynolds
Shari Nutter had a good knowledge of local market and she set up elisting emails for our specific area of interest. Shari was very accessible when needed by text, email, and phone, and she checked in with us regularly, and helped us navigate the buying and selling process by coordinating with other realtors, mortgage, and title company. We felt well taken care of and that everything was on track throughout the entire process. We would highly recommend Shari to buyers in the Fairfield/Hocking County area.
My Service Ratings
08/03/2018 - Tim Kelley
Shari Nutter was by far the best realtor we have ever dealt with and would recommend her services to anyone getting ready to list a home.
My Service Ratings
07/10/2018 - Bill Martini
As previously stated Shari was great to deal with. Made the process smooth and easy
My Service Ratings
12/12/2017 - Bill Beck - Pickerington OH
We bought a new home in Pickerington, and both bought and sold our homes thru Shari. Shari went above and beyond to make the whole buying and selling process smooth and stress free (or at least as stress free as buying/selling can possibly be LOL). She is professional, knowledgeable, always accessible, and a pleasure to work with. I would absolutely work with her again, she's one of the best in the business.
My Service Ratings
06/08/2017 - Sara Byers
My husband and I came with many questions and needed Shari to explain much of the process to us. Shari never seemed put off or too busy to help. She was extremely accessible and accommodating to our needs. Shari was genuinely invested in our investment. It felt like she was purchasing the house with us.
